Which Account Do You Draw From First

Which retirement account should you draw from first? It is one of the most important questions in retirement planning for women, and one of the least discussed. A good retirement withdrawal strategy can lower your taxes and help your savings last years longer. Women tend to live longer than men and often spend part of retirement on their own, so the order matters even more. Here is how to think about it.

The three types of accounts

Most women reach retirement with money in three places. Each one is taxed differently.

  • Regular investment accounts. You have already paid tax on this money. You pay tax only on the interest, dividends and gains.
  • Traditional retirement accounts. These include traditional IRAs and most 401(k) plans. You have not paid tax yet. Every dollar you take out is taxed as income.
  • Roth accounts. You paid the tax up front. Withdrawals in retirement are tax-free.

The order you use them decides how much goes to taxes and how much stays with you.

The usual order

The traditional advice is simple. Spend from regular investment accounts first. Then traditional retirement accounts. Save Roth accounts for last.

The reason is growth. Money in retirement accounts grows without being taxed each year. The longer you leave it alone, the more it can grow. Roth money is the most valuable because it will never be taxed again.

This order is a good starting point. It is not always the best answer.

When the usual order is wrong

Many women have a few low-income years early in retirement. The paycheck has stopped. Social Security has not started. In those years your tax rate may be the lowest it will ever be.

That is a good time to take some money from your traditional retirement accounts, even if you do not need all of it. You pay tax at a low rate now and avoid a higher rate later.

If you leave those accounts untouched, they keep growing. Then the government requires you to start taking money out, and the withdrawals can be large enough to push you into a higher tax bracket.

Required withdrawals

You cannot leave money in a traditional retirement account forever. Required withdrawals begin at age 73. If you were born in 1960 or later, they begin at 75.

The amount is set by a formula, and it rises as you age. You pay income tax on it whether you need the money or not. Roth IRAs have no required withdrawals during your lifetime.

Planning ahead keeps these withdrawals from becoming a tax problem in your late 70s and 80s.

Why this matters more for women

Three facts make the order more important for women.

You are likely to live longer. A woman who reaches 65 can expect to live into her mid-80s, and many live well past 90. Your money has to last longer, so every dollar lost to avoidable tax costs more.

You may be on your own. Most married women outlive their husbands. A widow files taxes as a single person. The same income is taxed at higher rates than it was for the couple. Tax-free Roth money is especially useful in those years.

Your Social Security decision is connected. Drawing from savings first can let you wait to claim Social Security. Waiting means a larger check for the rest of your life. For a woman who lives to 90, that is a meaningful difference.

If you live in Illinois

Illinois does not tax withdrawals from retirement accounts or Social Security. It does tax interest, dividends and gains in a regular investment account.

That means federal tax is what drives your withdrawal decisions here. State tax matters mostly for what you hold outside your retirement accounts.

Keep a cash reserve

Whatever order you choose, keep one to two years of spending in cash. Markets fall from time to time. Cash lets you leave your investments alone until they recover.

Selling investments during a downturn to pay the bills does lasting damage, especially early in retirement.

A simple way to start

  1. List every account and which of the three types it is.
  2. Add up the income you can count on: Social Security, pensions and any other regular payments.
  3. Find the gap between that income and what you spend.
  4. Decide each year which account fills the gap at the lowest tax cost.
  5. Review it every year. Your income and the tax rules will change.

Frequently asked questions

Which retirement account should I withdraw from first?

Usually a regular investment account first, traditional retirement accounts next and Roth accounts last. In low-income years, taking some from a traditional account earlier can lower your lifetime taxes.

When do required withdrawals start?

At age 73. If you were born in 1960 or later, at age 75.

Should I spend my Roth IRA last?

In most cases, yes. Roth money grows tax-free and has no required withdrawals during your lifetime.

Does Illinois tax IRA withdrawals?

No. Illinois does not tax withdrawals from IRAs or 401(k) plans. Federal tax still applies.

Why does withdrawal order matter more for women?

Women tend to live longer and are more likely to spend years as a single taxpayer. Both make tax planning more valuable.

Next step

There is no single right order for everyone. The right order is the one built around your accounts, your income and your life.

Fortis works with women in Chicago and across Illinois to build retirement income plans that last. To talk through which accounts to draw from and when, schedule a confidential conversation.

This article is for general education and is not legal, tax or investment advice. Tax laws change and every situation is different. Consult a tax professional about your own circumstances.

Questions about your own situation?

Discover more from Fortis Portfolio Solutions

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading