How to fire your financial advisor without a scene, a penalty or an awkward lunch.
Most people stay with an advisor they have outgrown for the same reason they keep a gym membership. Cancelling feels like a confrontation.
It isn’t. You don’t even have to make the call.
When it is time to fire your financial advisor
Nobody leaves over one bad quarter, and nobody should. These are the signs that hold up:
- You cannot say what you pay. Not roughly. At all.
- Your calls are returned by someone new every year.
- You hear from the firm mainly when it has something to sell.
- You ask a question and receive a brochure.
- Your life changed. Your portfolio did not.
One of these is an irritation. Three is a pattern.
You do not have to break up in person
This is the part most people don’t know. You do not close the old account. You open the new one.
Brokerage firms have a standing arrangement for this, called ACATS. It is the system they all use to move accounts between one another. Your new advisor prepares one form. You sign it. The system notifies your old firm, and the rules require them to cooperate. FINRA explains the process here.
Your old advisor finds out the way most of us find out about things now. By notification.
If you would like to send a note, send one. Two sentences is plenty. You are not required to explain.
What moves, and what doesn’t
Stocks, bonds and ETFs usually move exactly as they are. Nothing is sold, so the move itself does not create a tax bill.
Some things do not travel well. A fund that only your old firm offers may have to be sold or left behind. An annuity may carry a charge for leaving early. Ask about both before you sign, not after.
This is one reason we build portfolios from individual stocks, bonds and ETFs. You can always take them with you. We would rather you stay because you want to.
What it costs to leave
Usually less than staying. Check three things:
- Your agreement. Many ask for written notice, often 30 days. If you paid a fee in advance, ask for the unused part back.
- The transfer fee. The old firm may charge one for closing the account. Ask your new advisor whether they cover it.
- Surrender charges. These apply to some annuities and insurance products, and they can be large. Get the number in writing.
How long it takes
About a week for most accounts. Retirement accounts and money held at a bank or fund company can take longer. Leave the accounts alone while they are in transit. This is not the week to place a trade.
Do these in order
- Save your records first. Download statements, tax forms and what you paid for each holding. Your online login may stop working once the account moves.
- Choose the new advisor before you leave the old one. Here is what to look for.
- Sign the transfer form. The new firm does the rest.
- Check that everything arrived. Compare the new statement with the old one, line by line.
Not sure you are ready to leave? You don’t have to decide yet. Our complimentary analysis looks at what you own, what you pay and how much risk you are taking. Sometimes the answer is that your advisor is doing fine. We will tell you that too.
It is your money. It goes where you go.
Fortis Private Wealth is a fee-only fiduciary advisor in Chicago, with offices downtown and in East Lakeview.
Transfer times and fees vary by firm and account type. For informational purposes only. Not investment, tax or legal advice.