If you’re looking for a good fee-only financial advisor in Chicago, you want more than someone to manage a portfolio. You want someone who helps you make sound decisions, keeps the IRS’s share to what is actually owed, and lets you stop thinking about money at 3 a.m.
Chicago has no shortage of candidates. Stand at LaSalle and Monroe at lunchtime and you could collect a dozen business cards without moving your feet. Finding the right one is closer to finding a needle in a haystack, except that every piece of hay has a firm handshake and a nice suit.
That’s what makes it hard. Most financial advisors are charming because, for many of them, it is a sales role. So yes, listen to your gut. My children call it a “good vibe,” and it counts. But charm is the one qualification nearly everyone in this business has, so it can’t be the only test.
Independent advice, transparent pricing, and a fiduciary commitment are the minimum. What people overlook is the investment management itself: who actually decides what you own, and why. We think that piece matters most, and we’ll get to it.
First, a quick welcome to the Fortis Private Wealth blog. We offer a family office atmosphere to high-net-worth families in Chicagoland and beyond. We don’t farm out the investment management. We do it in-house, and we know our clients personally.
Now, the basics.
What Is a Fee-Only Financial Advisor?
A fee-only financial advisor is paid by you and by no one else. No commissions, and no payments from the companies whose products end up in your account.
It matters because people tend to recommend what they are paid to recommend. That is less a comment on character than on incentives.
There are three common compensation structures:
- Fee-only: Paid directly by clients, with no commissions on products.
- Fee-based: Charges fees and may also collect commissions. The name sounds nearly identical to fee-only, which is unlikely to be an accident.
- Commission-based: Paid by the products and transactions they sell.
A fee-only advisor may bill hourly, charge a flat fee or retainer, or take a percentage of assets under management (AUM). The method varies. The source of the money doesn’t: it’s you.
- Look for a Financial Advisor Who Is a Fiduciary
Ask every prospective advisor one question: are you a fiduciary 100% of the time when working with me?
A fiduciary is legally required to put your interests ahead of their own. The answer should be a simple yes. If it arrives with footnotes, or you can’t follow it, treat that as a red flag.
Don’t assume the title settles it. “Financial advisor” is a job description anyone can print on a card, and some advisors act as fiduciaries for part of the relationship and as salespeople for the rest.
Then ask what else they get paid. Referral fees, commissions, and revenue-sharing payments from third parties are known outside the financial industry as kickbacks. A good advisor will explain exactly how they are compensated, including any benefits from their custodian, their firm, and the investments they offer.
This has become murkier with the rise of alternative assets, mostly private offerings. Watch for items like a “due diligence fee”: a payment from the product’s sponsor to the firm recommending it, nominally for vetting the deal. Being paid by the seller to evaluate the seller’s product is an interesting definition of diligence.
- Find Someone Who Understands Your Financial Situation
The right advisor for your neighbor may be the wrong one for you. A Chicago executive earning $500,000 with a pile of company stock has different problems than a retired couple living on a $3 million portfolio. A business owner preparing to sell has different problems again, most of them involving taxes.
Look for someone who has already worked with people in your position. Depending on your situation, that may mean experience with:
- Retirement income that lasts as long as you do
- Tax-efficient investing and tax planning
- Stock options, restricted stock units (RSUs), and concentrated stock positions
- Selling a business
- Estate planning and wealth transfer, including Illinois’s own estate tax, which starts well below the federal exemption
- Charitable giving
- Divorce, widowhood, and other major transitions
- Coordinating decisions between spouses
If you have accumulated significant wealth, a diversified portfolio and a pat on the head won’t do. You need someone who understands how the parts of your financial life fit together, and who can explain it without making it more complicated than it is. Complexity is easy to sell. Clarity takes more work.
- Understand How Much a Fee-Only Financial Advisor Costs
What does a fee-only financial advisor in Chicago cost? It depends on what you need, but you should always be able to get the answer in dollars.
| Fee structure | How it works | Best suited to |
| Hourly | You pay for the advisor’s time | A specific question, such as a retirement decision or a portfolio review |
| Flat fee | A set price for a plan or a defined scope of work | A one-time financial plan |
| Retainer | An ongoing fee for continuing advice | Heavy planning needs with little to manage |
| Assets under management (AUM) | A percentage of the investments the advisor manages | Ongoing investment management |
The percentage model is the most common, and it deserves the most scrutiny. One percent sounds modest. On a $2 million portfolio it is $20,000 a year, every year, and it rises as your account does.
Whether that is fair depends on what it buys. If the advisor does the investment work personally, building and watching your portfolio and coordinating it with your taxes and estate plan, a percentage can be money well spent. If your money goes into a model portfolio run by someone else while your advisor takes you to lunch, you are paying a great deal for lunch.
Ask two things before signing. What is my total annual cost in dollars, including fund expenses and any planning fees? And who is actually managing the money?
- Look for an Advisor Who Provides Comprehensive Financial Planning
Investment management is the engine, but it needs somewhere to go. Should you sell appreciated stock to fund retirement, or draw from the IRA first? Should you convert part of a traditional IRA to a Roth? How much can you give your children without shortchanging yourself? Are you taking more risk than you need to?
None of these can be answered from a portfolio statement alone. Each depends on your taxes, your estate plan, your insurance, your spending, and what you want the money to do.
A good advisor connects the investment decisions to all of it and then helps you decide. Be wary of the leather-bound financial plan, delivered with ceremony and never opened again. A plan in a drawer has never funded a retirement.
- Ask About the Advisor’s Investment Philosophy
This is the part most people skip and, in our view, the part that matters most. Two fee-only advisors can invest in entirely different ways. Some use low-cost index funds. Others pick individual securities, manage actively, or use alternative investments.
Ask how they build portfolios, how they manage risk, what the investments cost, and what would make them change course. Then ask how any of it connects to your goals.
Be careful with past performance. An advisor who leads with superior returns should make you nervous, because it may mean they take more risk than your situation calls for. Anyone can look brilliant in a bull market.
If you have $3 million, beating an index is probably not your real concern. Reliable income, a sensible tax bill, and no unpleasant surprises probably are. Peace of mind is what most of our clients value most, and it comes in different shapes and sizes.
Finally, the advisor should be able to explain all of this in plain English. If you leave the meeting impressed but unable to repeat what was said, the jargon did its job and the advisor didn’t.
- Check the Advisor’s Credentials and Background
Before hiring a financial advisor in Chicago, do some homework. It takes about twenty minutes and it’s free. Years of experience and a clean regulatory record count for more than letters after a name.
- SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure. Look up the advisor and the firm. Read the Form ADV and the relationship summary for services, compensation, conflicts of interest, and disciplinary history. If you can’t find a prospective advisor here at all, that is the biggest red flag there is.
- FINRA BrokerCheck. Worth a look if the advisor ever worked at a brokerage.
- NAPFA. The National Association of Personal Financial Advisors keeps a directory of fee-only advisors. Membership tells you how someone is paid. It is no substitute for checking the record yourself.
- CFP Board. Verify a CFP® certification here. It isn’t the most critical item, but it gives you a sense of training. Many advisors who serve ultra-high-net-worth clients found the designation useful early in their careers and no longer hold it.
A word on reading the record. Financial advisors, like doctors, rarely get through a long career without someone being unhappy. One client who disliked the returns on a plain large-cap stock portfolio is very different from a string of complaints about serious misconduct. Look for patterns.
And don’t hire on credentials alone. Judgment, experience, and the ability to listen don’t come with a certificate.
- Interview More Than One Financial Advisor
You are hiring someone who will know more about your finances than most of your family does. Meet at least two or three before deciding.
Seven questions worth asking:
- Are you fee-only, and do you or your firm receive any commissions?
- Are you a fiduciary at all times when advising me?
- How do you charge, and what will my total annual cost be in dollars?
- What types of clients do you typically work with?
- Who manages the investments, and how do you approach tax planning alongside them?
- How often will we meet, and who will actually be working on my plan?
- What happens if my financial situation changes significantly?
Then pay attention to how they answer. Do they listen? Do they ask about you, or mostly talk about themselves? Can they explain something complicated without making you feel slow?
One more tell. Clients tell us that when an advisor spends the meeting running down competitors, it is a turn-off. It should be. Someone confident in their own work has better things to talk about.
How Do You Know You’ve Found the Right Fee-Only Financial Advisor in Chicago?
You’ll know by what you can say after the first meeting. You understand what you are paying and what you are getting. You know who manages the money and how. Your questions got straight answers, and the fiduciary question got a one-word answer.
The right advisor may or may not have the largest firm or the best view of the lake. Office square footage has no known correlation with investment results.
Start with the decisions you need help making. Interview advisors who have handled them before, check their records, and consult your gut last, once the facts are in. The good vibe is the tiebreaker.
If you’d like to see how we would approach your situation, we’re happy to talk. Please schedule a confidential conversation.
For informational prurposes only. Not investment advice